Dear Cookies,
I did not want to read Steinbeck's book, I did not purposely vote for it. I had read "the pearl" many years ago and is still a book I remember, the kind of story that remains, engraved forever in your mind. In that book, as in this one, you can feel the tragedy coming slowly but irreversibly as you advance on each page. You can deeply feel sorrow, injustice and the unfair situation of the poor and the ignorants. Steinbeck is damn good to masterly describe that kind of situations, the kind of writer that deserves a Nobel prize, but that shocks those that read him and even more those that dare to do it twice.I think this book is more than great. On one hand we have a perfect, sharp description of a part of the american society in the thirties of the 20th century. Clear as a picture. Everything from the clothes or the food to the cars or technologies used to crop (to me, having studied agriculture, is amazing to discover that theree was not machinery available to pick the cotton on that time). The roles of each one in these family groups, the social cliches, the prejudices and hierarchies, everything detailed. That is the history book. But in the other hand it is an actual text, a description of things that are currently happening all around the world, not only in Spain, or in the US, but also, as you have said, in developing countries, all around the world. I guess abuse of power, injustice and hunger is something inherently attached to the human beings that will happen once and once again, wherever, always.The end of the book is as good as the rest of it. Tom goes away, as others before him, he will never be back. The flood, the Nature, spoils the little things the Joads still had. The coming baby, the hope, the future, is not a baby anymore. We do not know the sins of John, we do not need to know, he will pay for them anyway. We do not know the fate of the remaining members of the family, but we can imagine that they will do the same as the rest of the okies: to suffer, to die sooner than later in misery, it does not matter how. That is irrelevant, the book is elegant enough not to make us read that. We can only hope that they will manage to survive, in order to not to feel too sorry for them, maybe guilty. Then we close the book, and go back to our reality, hard as it can be, but that is not the same as the one of the miserable, of those that have lost everything and are starving.I did not want to read this book. I was sure that it was going to make me thirsty, hungry, cold, tired. Nothing good. But also angry, impotent, desperate. It is so terribly good, actual and real that it will stay carved in my memory, as the one from the same author I mentioned above. I will have to think about ethics, about society and about Justice, while at the same time people around us are desperately looking for a job, searching food in the trash or sleeping in the streets.I will bear the burden of this two books, I only hope we will choose, in our always interesting club, a new one, lighter to read and not to carry on our shoulders.
I finished to book a couple days ago. I thought, now I need something to cheer me up, to help me forget... and I took a book about concentration camps, because that story, I already know... the misery that we live with "The grapes of wrath" is so unfair and so real, that you almost want to forget about it immediately, but you can't. As Jorge said, certain things, stay with you, and this is not something that we can just wash away with any "Bridget Jones" novel that we read after. But that is for the best, I guess... Human tragedy is all around us, so we don't have to live in suffering for that, but it is good that we don't forget.
ReplyDeleteWhat Steinbeck depicts is about 70 years ago, not so long, so look at it now, I would say, things have improved (at least in the USA), so why couldn't it get better in other places? It always takes hard work, blood, tears, but in time, no matter who or where, can go forward. That's what I believe.
Oh, so sorry guys, I didn’t mean to upset you! :-(
ReplyDeleteJ, very good and deep reflection.
I am also touched by the book. The story is rough, very easy to believe. No fiction at all, as real as life. Every chapter I was hoping things would get better, they deserved some luck, just a little, but it never did. Things can always get worse (and they do). I am impressed by the end. This book does feel heavy on one’s shoulders.
We might not like it, but I think we need to know about these realities. We cannot forget them; if we do, they are bound to happen again. I believe that the next time I see immigrants working in our rural areas, I will see them with different eyes.
I agree with Rocio: there is hope. The path is not easy, especially if we look at the little interest the politicians and the powerful have in changing and improving people’s lives. But we have seen it happen in the past, people fighting for their rights and succeeding. I am sure we will see it happen again and again.
Despite the bad taste the story leaves in your mouth, I have to say that this is one of the best books I have ever read. The style, the story, the descriptions, the characters … I think this is a master piece.
Now, let’s move on to something fun to start 2014!! Happy holidays to all the cookies and I hope 2014 brings many good reads!
I am happy that I finally dare reading Steinbeck, so many thanks for the "push", Arantxa.
DeleteIt has been a bittersweet experience, but very much worth the "bitter".
Having said that, I hope the start of 2014 will bring us something funny, easy, and/or light :-)
Dear Jorge
ReplyDeleteI have been meaning to post a comment to let you know that I couldn't agree more with you.
In fact, I also wanted to say it on behalf of Chon, our omnipresent but not visible member :-)
We were commenting on how the sensations that emerge while reading, really stay in your memory for ever, and so does the book. You expressed the feeling very accurately. It makes the reading harsh, but so much needed
Touching post, Jorge, for a wonderful book that you could read no matter in which moment of history and the essence would prevail. Human nature at its purest state. When we are disposed of all material layers, and the plundering goes on without limits. What is left of a being then? Steinbeck gives the answer at the very end of the book. He already gave us a hint when he advanced that the poor will help the poor and this how the book finishes: There is hope, the girl smiles, the dying man is helped, they'll help each other. They will keep on fighting. They are still human beings.
ReplyDelete